A person’s environment affects the
way they live and think because it strongly affects what influences they are
exposed to and what opportunities they have. Have you noticed that the topic
that many novels are focused upon is how an environment can affect its
characters? Well Wuthering Heights is one of those books. Throughout the novel,
Emily Brontё describes two manors, Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange.
Although they are not far from each other, both locations are extremely
different and the people that live on each manor contrast due to their disparate
environments.
Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross
Grange are in many ways set in opposition to each other. The Heights sits
exposed on a stormy hilltop, but the Grange is calm and protected down in the
valley. Wuthering Heights is the estate of the Earnshaw family and it’s located
on England’s Yorkshire moors. Wuthering Heights is described by Mr. Lockwood, a
tenant at neighboring Thrushcross Grange, as desolate and the “perfect
misanthropist's heaven” (1). The house itself seems dark and forbidding which is
mostly likely used to cater to the gothic element of the novel. Throughout the
book, Wuthering Heights is associated with stormy weather which explains the
name of the manor. 'Wuthering' being a significant adjective, descriptive of
the atmospheric disorder to which its station is exposed in stormy weather. In
contrast, Thrushcross Grange is the home of the Linton Family and it is much
lighter and more orderly than the Heights. Thrushcross Grange is described as
filled with light and warmth. Unlike Wuthering Heights, it is “elegant and
comfortable-a splendid place carpeted with crimson, and crimson covered chairs
and tables, and a pure white ceiling bordered by gold” (10). Thrushcross Grange
had a much more refined and pleasant appearance.
There are tons of differences in
the residents of these two places as well. For example, Edgar grew up with his
sister Isabella and is fair, well educated and quite the opposite of
Heathcliff. If Heathcliff represents the Heights then Edgar represents the
Grange in that he is civilized yet sheltered and quite dull. Emily Brontë uses
the setting of Wuthering Heights to extend how the novel uses contrasting
characters to support the theme of Good vs. Evil. It is not just the homes alone
that contrast but more importantly the individuals that emerge from each place
and mirror its setting. Wuthering Heights are packed with the working class
whereas Thrushcross grange has residents who belong to a higher level in the
social ladder. The Earnshaws are wild and passionate while the Lintons are tame
and civilized.
Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross
Grange, illustrate this concept, as they are double opposites in the story. The
physical characteristics of the two places and the people that reside there are
the driving forces for this opposition. With the union of Cathy and Hareton,
the barriers of class are finally broken and the two incompatible worlds of
Thrushcross Grange and Wuthering Heights blend together in harmony. They
achieve in life what Heathcliff and Catherine can only achieve in death.
Although we discussed a lot about the setting of the two properties, your post offers some more insight on the concept! I Really like your concluding paragraph as you hone in on the clash of Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange and how the social class system is broken with the union of Hareton and Cathy. Your claim of Cathy and Hareton achieving peace and harmony as they live while Heathcliff and Catherine can only achieve that in death compels me and I agree completely. The two couples in the first generation were so unhappy as they were separated as they lived and could only reunite in death. On the other hand, Cathy and Hareton find their love for eachother as they live and are able to express it freely, which is what Heathcliff and Catherine essentially died for. I think you did a fair job in discussing why Brontё would have these two properties contrast each other so drastically, which as you said, is to support the thematic idea of good vs. evil and how the characters mirror the setting. I would have liked it if you discussed more so the fact of the two houses interactions and how the two places affected one another as far as characters and significance to the novel go. However, the good quality of your post makes up for it so I for one am satisfied!
ReplyDeleteHeyyyyy Bethany! So I agree with Ciya- your post offers some more interesting insight through your analysis of the setting. One thing I liked most of all about your post was how you referred to the denizens of both Thrushcross Grange & Wuthering Heights as "driving forces for this opposition". Emily Brontë was definitely on to something when creating the characters and the setting(s) in which they reside, and you explicated that fully. I also appreciate the comparison of how the Lintons are tame while the Earnshaws are wild and passionate, because I hadn't really been able to find the words myself to compare them side by side. Overall I think your blog is very thorough and I love it.
ReplyDelete